Buffalo Nickel For Sale

Looking for Buffalo Nickel? We feature Buffalo Nickel for sale online. Find Buffalo Nickel for sale on eBay!

The First Commemorative Mint Buffalo Nickel Certificate If Authenticity

The First Commemorative

The First Commemorative Mint Buffalo Nickel Certificate If Authenticity $9.99

Read Details
1914 Proof Buffalo Nickel Graded Pf 66 By Ngc! Great Toning! Only 1275 Minted!

1914 Proof Buffalo

1914 Proof Buffalo Nickel Graded Pf 66 By Ngc! Great Toning! Only 1275 Minted! $2,159.99

Read Details
1916-s 5c Ms64 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel---

1916-s 5c

1916-s 5c Ms64 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel--- $2,140.00

Read Details
1914-s Buffalo Nickel, Ms65, Pcgs

1914-s Buffalo

1914-s Buffalo Nickel, Ms65, Pcgs $2,150.00

Read Details
1936 Pcgs Pr66+ Satin Buffalo Nickel

1936 Pcgs Pr66

1936 Pcgs Pr66+ Satin Buffalo Nickel $2,145.00

Read Details
1938-d/s 5c Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms67*

1938-d/s

1938-d/s 5c Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms67* $2,100.00

Read Details
1918/7-d Us Buffalo Nickel 5c - Pcgs F15

1918/7-d

1918/7-d Us Buffalo Nickel 5c - Pcgs F15 $2,125.00

Read Details
1925-s  Buffalo Nickel - Ngc Ms64 - Super Clean - Rare Date ! <

1925-s Buffalo

1925-s Buffalo Nickel - Ngc Ms64 - Super Clean - Rare Date ! < $2,100.00

Read Details
1914-s Pcgs Buffalo Nickel Ms 65 ** Free Shipping!

1914-s Pcgs

1914-s Pcgs Buffalo Nickel Ms 65 ** Free Shipping! $2,100.00

Read Details
1919-d Ngc Ms64 Buffalo Nickel

1919-d Ngc

1919-d Ngc Ms64 Buffalo Nickel $2,100.00

Read Details
1915 D Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms 65

1915 D Buffalo

1915 D Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms 65 $2,099.99

Read Details
1917-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-63 Premium Quality! Cac Approved!

1917-s Buffalo

1917-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-63 Premium Quality! Cac Approved! $2,095.00

Read Details
1915 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-67

1915 Buffalo Nickel

1915 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-67 $2,094.75

Read Details
1918 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-66

1918 Buffalo Nickel

1918 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-66 $2,094.75

Read Details
1919-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-64

1919-s Buffalo

1919-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-64 $2,094.75

Read Details
1929-d Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-66

1929-d Buffalo

1929-d Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-66 $2,094.75

Read Details
1921-s Buffalo Nickel Ngc Au-58 Cac

1921-s Buffalo

1921-s Buffalo Nickel Ngc Au-58 Cac $2,094.75

Read Details
1918 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms66 (cac)

1918 5c Buffalo

1918 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms66 (cac) $2,093.50

Read Details
1937-d 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel Ms-61 Ngc

1937-d 3

1937-d 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel Ms-61 Ngc $2,086.45

Read Details
1937-d Buffalo Nickel - 3 Legs Ngc Ms-61

1937-d Buffalo

1937-d Buffalo Nickel - 3 Legs Ngc Ms-61 $2,075.00

Read Details
1928-s 5c Pcgs Ms65 - Frosty Luster - Buffalo Nickel - Frosty Luster

1928-s 5c

1928-s 5c Pcgs Ms65 - Frosty Luster - Buffalo Nickel - Frosty Luster $2,070.00

Read Details
1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel   Ngc Pf66

1913 Type 2

1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Pf66 $2,050.00

Read Details
1918-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-63

1918-s Buffalo

1918-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-63 $2,047.50

Read Details
1936 Pcgs/cac Pr66 Satin Buffalo Nickel

1936 Pcgs/cac

1936 Pcgs/cac Pr66 Satin Buffalo Nickel $2,025.00

Read Details
1937 Pcgs Pr67 Buffalo Nickel

1937 Pcgs Pr67

1937 Pcgs Pr67 Buffalo Nickel $2,025.00

Read Details
1914-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-65 Cac

1914-s Buffalo

1914-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-65 Cac $2,021.25

Read Details
4000 Mixed Buffalo Nickel Coins (lot) // Mixed Date/mint // 100 Rolls + Bonus

4000 Mixed Buffalo

4000 Mixed Buffalo Nickel Coins (lot) // Mixed Date/mint // 100 Rolls + Bonus $1,999.98

Read Details
4000 Mixed Buffalo Nickel Coins (lot) // Mixed Date/mint // 100 Rolls + Bonus.

4000 Mixed Buffalo

4000 Mixed Buffalo Nickel Coins (lot) // Mixed Date/mint // 100 Rolls + Bonus. $1,999.98

Read Details
4000 Mixed Buffalo Nickel Bag (lot) // Mixed Date/mint // 100 Rolls + Bonus

4000 Mixed Buffalo

4000 Mixed Buffalo Nickel Bag (lot) // Mixed Date/mint // 100 Rolls + Bonus $1,999.98

Read Details
Buffalo Nickel Lot (4000 Piece) No Date Mint Marked With A Bottle Of Nic-a-date

Buffalo Nickel Lot

Buffalo Nickel Lot (4000 Piece) No Date Mint Marked With A Bottle Of Nic-a-date $2,000.00

Read Details
1935 Buffalo Nickel 5c Coin - Certified Pcgs Ms67+ Plus Grade - $3,000 Value!

1935 Buffalo Nickel

1935 Buffalo Nickel 5c Coin - Certified Pcgs Ms67+ Plus Grade - $3,000 Value! $2,016.30

Read Details
1913-s Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms66 Toned Cac Green Sticker Approved - 03507

1913-s Type

1913-s Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms66 Toned Cac Green Sticker Approved - 03507 $1,995.00

Read Details
1-1920,2-1924, 1-1927 Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Five Cent 5c Coin- All 4 Nickel

1-1920,2

1-1920,2-1924, 1-1927 Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Five Cent 5c Coin- All 4 Nickel $2,000.00

Read Details
1926-d Buffalo Nickel, Ms64, Pcgs

1926-d Buffalo

1926-d Buffalo Nickel, Ms64, Pcgs $2,000.00

Read Details
1937 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms67+        83640150c

1937 5c Buffalo

1937 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms67+ 83640150c $2,000.00

Read Details
5 Rolls 100 Coins 2020 Highland Buffalo Nickel Design 1 Oz Silver Round Sku59282

5 Rolls 100

5 Rolls 100 Coins 2020 Highland Buffalo Nickel Design 1 Oz Silver Round Sku59282 $2,000.00

Read Details
1924 Pcgs Ms66 Buffalo Nickel

1924 Pcgs Ms66

1924 Pcgs Ms66 Buffalo Nickel $2,000.00

Read Details
1924 5c Pcgs Ms 66 ~ Low Pop High Grade Gem Buffalo Nickel

1924 5c Pcgs

1924 5c Pcgs Ms 66 ~ Low Pop High Grade Gem Buffalo Nickel $1,999.95

Read Details
1920-d Buffalo Nickel Mint State  +++++

1920-d Buffalo

1920-d Buffalo Nickel Mint State +++++ $1,999.00

Read Details
1918/7-d Buffalo Nickel - Icg Certified Ef 45 Details - Rare Overdate - Jf303

1918/7-d

1918/7-d Buffalo Nickel - Icg Certified Ef 45 Details - Rare Overdate - Jf303 $1,995.00

Read Details
Dansco #7112 Complete 1913-38 Buffalo Nickel 5c 64 Coin Circulated Set

Dansco #7112 Complete

Dansco #7112 Complete 1913-38 Buffalo Nickel 5c 64 Coin Circulated Set $1,995.00

Read Details
1919-d Buffalo Nickel Certified Ngc Ms 64 5-cents ~ Old "fattie" Holder

1919-d Buffalo

1919-d Buffalo Nickel Certified Ngc Ms 64 5-cents ~ Old "fattie" Holder $1,995.00

Read Details
1913-d 5c Pcgs Ms66 (type 2) Buffalo Nickel

1913-d 5c

1913-d 5c Pcgs Ms66 (type 2) Buffalo Nickel $1,990.00

Read Details
1918/7-d Buffalo Nickel.  Full Horn.  X.f. Detail.  131261

1918/7-d

1918/7-d Buffalo Nickel. Full Horn. X.f. Detail. 131261 $1,975.00

Read Details
1926 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-67

1926 Buffalo Nickel

1926 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-67 $1,968.75

Read Details
1913-d T-2 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-66

1913-d T

1913-d T-2 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-66 $1,968.75

Read Details
1937-d Us Buffalo Nickel 5c - 3 Legged - Ngc Ms62

1937-d Us

1937-d Us Buffalo Nickel 5c - 3 Legged - Ngc Ms62 $1,965.00

Read Details
1937 Pcgs/cac Pr66 Buffalo Nickel

1937 Pcgs/cac

1937 Pcgs/cac Pr66 Buffalo Nickel $1,965.00

Read Details
1918/7-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Ngc F12

1918/7-d

1918/7-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Ngc F12 $1,957.00

Read Details
1918/7-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Ngc Fine Details

1918/7-d

1918/7-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Ngc Fine Details $1,950.00

Read Details
1919-s Buffalo Nickel 5c Ngc Ms63 Mint Error 10% Off-center, Super Rare!

1919-s Buffalo

1919-s Buffalo Nickel 5c Ngc Ms63 Mint Error 10% Off-center, Super Rare! $1,946.10

Read Details
1923-s Buffalo Nickel Ms-64 Ngc Cac - Sku#193779

1923-s Buffalo

1923-s Buffalo Nickel Ms-64 Ngc Cac - Sku#193779 $1,946.64

Read Details
1916-s 5c Pcgs Ms65 - Better S-mint - Buffalo Nickel - Better S-mint

1916-s 5c

1916-s 5c Pcgs Ms65 - Better S-mint - Buffalo Nickel - Better S-mint $1,930.00

Read Details
1931-s 5c Ms66 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel---

1931-s 5c

1931-s 5c Ms66 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel--- $1,900.00

Read Details
1938-d Buffalo Nickel 5c ✬✬✬ 100% Guaranteed Natural Monster Neon Toned!

1938-d Buffalo

1938-d Buffalo Nickel 5c ✬✬✬ 100% Guaranteed Natural Monster Neon Toned! $1,899.00

Read Details
1913 D T2 Pcgs Ms66 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel

1913 D T2

1913 D T2 Pcgs Ms66 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel $1,899.99

Read Details
1913 S Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms 66 Type 1 Cac Toned

1913 S Buffalo

1913 S Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms 66 Type 1 Cac Toned $1,899.99

Read Details
Usa Seller  1936 S  Pcgs  67 Cac Sticker   Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping Us Only

Usa Seller 1936

Usa Seller 1936 S Pcgs 67 Cac Sticker Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping Us Only $1,895.95

Read Details
1937-d "3 Legs" Buffalo Nickel "pcgs Au Scratch" *free S/h After 1st Item*

1937-d "3

1937-d "3 Legs" Buffalo Nickel "pcgs Au Scratch" *free S/h After 1st Item* $1,889.95

Read Details
1937 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Pr-67 Cac

1937 Buffalo Nickel

1937 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Pr-67 Cac $1,884.75

Read Details
1913-s T-2 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-64+ Cac

1913-s T

1913-s T-2 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-64+ Cac $1,884.75

Read Details
1929-d 5c Pcgs Ms66 - Buffalo Nickel

1929-d 5c

1929-d 5c Pcgs Ms66 - Buffalo Nickel $1,880.00

Read Details
1930 5c Ms66 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel---

1930 5c Ms66

1930 5c Ms66 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel--- $1,840.00

Read Details
1913 5c Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms67+ (cac)

1913 5c Type

1913 5c Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms67+ (cac) $1,850.00

Read Details
1917-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-64 Old Rattler Holder

1917-s Buffalo

1917-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-64 Old Rattler Holder $1,850.00

Read Details
1921 S Buffalo Indian Head Nickel Very Appealing Key Date Sharp Horn Pcgs Au 55*

1921 S Buffalo

1921 S Buffalo Indian Head Nickel Very Appealing Key Date Sharp Horn Pcgs Au 55* $1,840.00

Read Details
1919-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-63

1919-s Buffalo

1919-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-63 $1,837.50

Read Details
1913-s 5c Type 2 Pcgs Ms64 Cac Buffalo Nickel (multi-colored Iridescence!)

1913-s 5c

1913-s 5c Type 2 Pcgs Ms64 Cac Buffalo Nickel (multi-colored Iridescence!) $1,818.00

Read Details
1936-d 5¢ Buffalo Nickel – 3 1/2 Legs – Pcgs F 12 Cac – Rare Variety!

1936-d 5

1936-d 5¢ Buffalo Nickel – 3 1/2 Legs – Pcgs F 12 Cac – Rare Variety! $1,830.00

Read Details
1913-d Buffalo Nickel Type-i Ms-67 Ngc - Sku#170877

1913-d Buffalo

1913-d Buffalo Nickel Type-i Ms-67 Ngc - Sku#170877 $1,819.64

Read Details
1913-d Buffalo Nickel Type-ii Ms-66 Pcgs - Sku #131938

1913-d Buffalo

1913-d Buffalo Nickel Type-ii Ms-66 Pcgs - Sku #131938 $1,819.64

Read Details
1920 S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Us Coin Ms 63 Pcgs

1920 S 5c

1920 S 5c Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Us Coin Ms 63 Pcgs $1,815.00

Read Details
1914-d 5c Ms62 Pcgs/cac- Buffalo Nickel---

1914-d 5c

1914-d 5c Ms62 Pcgs/cac- Buffalo Nickel--- $1,800.00

Read Details
1923 5c Ms65 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel---

1923 5c Ms65

1923 5c Ms65 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel--- $1,800.00

Read Details
1929-s 5c Ms65 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel---

1929-s 5c

1929-s 5c Ms65 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel--- $1,800.00

Read Details
1930 5c Ms66 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel---

1930 5c Ms66

1930 5c Ms66 Pcgs- Buffalo Nickel--- $1,800.00

Read Details
1913-s Type I Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms66 Cac  Strong Doubling Of Indian Portrait

1913-s Type

1913-s Type I Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms66 Cac Strong Doubling Of Indian Portrait $1,800.00

Read Details
1917-d 5c Pcgs Ms65 - Silky, White Gem - Buffalo Nickel - B9363

1917-d 5c

1917-d 5c Pcgs Ms65 - Silky, White Gem - Buffalo Nickel - B9363 $1,800.00

Read Details
1936-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Vf-20  3 1/2 Legs

1936-d 5c

1936-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Vf-20 3 1/2 Legs $1,800.00

Read Details
1914/3 5c Overdate Fs-101 Buffalo Nickel Uncirculated Details Toned Fs-14.87

1914/3 5c

1914/3 5c Overdate Fs-101 Buffalo Nickel Uncirculated Details Toned Fs-14.87 $1,795.00

Read Details
1921-s Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms62 Mint Error Obverse Lamination Key Date Ultra Rare

1921-s Buffalo

1921-s Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms62 Mint Error Obverse Lamination Key Date Ultra Rare $1,785.00

Read Details
1919-s Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-63

1919-s Buffalo

1919-s Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-63 $1,779.75

Read Details
1913-d T-1 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-67

1913-d T

1913-d T-1 Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms-67 $1,779.75

Read Details
1913-d T-1 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-67

1913-d T

1913-d T-1 Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-67 $1,779.75

Read Details
1915-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-64

1915-s Buffalo

1915-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-64 $1,779.75

Read Details
1914-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-65

1914-s Buffalo

1914-s Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms-65 $1,779.75

Read Details

When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.